Bob Pipeline Doctor

CI/CD failure triage powered by IBM Bob

IBM Bob IDE — core workflowLocal read-only MCPControlled CI fixture

How This Works

This dashboard renders a structured CI failure analysis produced by IBM Bob IDE using repository context and a local read-only MCP server.

CI Failure Captured

Controlled GitHub Actions failure fixture stored locally

Local MCP Exposes Artifacts

Read-only MCP server provides CI data to Bob IDE

IBM Bob Analyzes Context

Bob correlates log, repo files, and test output

Dashboard Renders Plan

Structured remediation with human review required

📋 For Judging

Exported IBM Bob IDE task reports and screenshots must be added to /bob_sessions before final submission. See docs/bob-session-notes.md for capture instructions.

Pipeline Failure

run_1042

Provider

GitHub Actions

Workflow

CI / Checkout Validation

Status

FAILED

Branch

main

Commit

fix-checkout-status-handling

Failed Step

npm test -- checkout

Timestamp

2026-05-16T21:00:00Z

Failure Diagnosis

REGRESSIONFailure type

Payment status validation is returning 'pending' for confirmed transactions, causing checkout tests to fail on main. The validatePaymentStatus function does not recognize 'confirmed' as an approved terminal state, which breaks the checkout flow for completed payments.

Probable Root Cause

Recent changes to lib/payments/validatePaymentStatus.ts appear to have omitted 'confirmed' from the APPROVED_STATUSES list. The payment provider returns 'confirmed' as the terminal state for a successful transaction, but the validation logic only recognizes 'approved' and 'captured'. All other statuses — including 'confirmed' — fall through to the 'pending' return path, blocking the checkout route from proceeding.

Evidence

→Test assertion failed: expected 'approved', received 'pending' in tests/checkout.test.ts at line 47
→Input to validatePaymentStatus: { status: 'confirmed', amount: 99.99, currency: 'USD' }
→The checkout route (app/api/checkout/route.ts) returns HTTP 402 when canProceed is false
→git diff HEAD~1 shows lib/payments/validatePaymentStatus.ts was modified in the failing commit
→Four other tests pass — the regression is specific to the 'confirmed' status handling

Impacted Files

4 files · risk: high

lib/payments/validatePaymentStatus.ts

HIGH

Contains the status normalization logic; 'confirmed' is missing from APPROVED_STATUSES, causing it to be treated as 'pending'

app/api/checkout/route.ts

HIGH

Depends directly on validatePaymentStatus result; returns HTTP 402 Payment Required when canProceed is false, blocking confirmed transactions

tests/checkout.test.ts

MEDIUM

Contains the failing test; may need assertion updates once root cause is confirmed and fixed, but test logic should not be changed just to make it pass

.github/workflows/ci.yml

LOW

CI workflow definition; low risk unless test runner configuration or timeout needs adjustment after fix

Affected systems:Checkout flowPayment status validationOrder confirmation

Safe Remediation Plan

⚠ HUMAN REVIEW REQUIRED BEFORE MERGE / DEPLOY

1.Review lib/payments/validatePaymentStatus.ts and identify all current entries in APPROVED_STATUSES
2.Check payment provider API documentation to confirm whether 'confirmed' is an official terminal approved state
3.If confirmed: add 'confirmed' to APPROVED_STATUSES and verify no other callers are affected
4.Update tests/checkout.test.ts only if the expected behavior changes — do not update the test just to pass it
5.Run npm test -- checkout locally before pushing to verify the fix
6.Request a second review from a team member familiar with the payment provider integration before merging

Safe Commands — Read-Only Investigation

$ git diff HEAD~1 lib/payments/validatePaymentStatus.ts

$ git log --oneline -10 -- lib/payments/

$ grep -rn 'confirmed\|approved\|captured' lib/payments/

$ grep -rn 'validatePaymentStatus' app/ lib/ tests/

$ npm test -- checkout

Recommended Tests

Add These Tests

+Unit test: validatePaymentStatus with status='confirmed' should return { normalizedStatus: 'approved', canProceed: true }
+Unit test: validatePaymentStatus with status='pending' should return { normalizedStatus: 'pending', canProceed: false }
+Integration test: POST /api/checkout with confirmed payment returns HTTP 200
+Integration test: POST /api/checkout with pending payment returns HTTP 402

Missing Coverage

✗No test covering the 'confirmed' status variant from the payment provider
✗No contract test verifying the complete list of status strings the payment provider can return
✗No test for payment provider response schema version changes

Merge Confidence / Release Readiness

/ 10

Not ready — do not merge

The root cause is probable but unconfirmed. The fix appears straightforward, but the payment provider status mapping has not been verified against the provider's official API documentation. Adding 'confirmed' to APPROVED_STATUSES without this verification risks accepting invalid statuses if the mapping assumption is wrong. Payment logic requires careful human review before any change is merged to main.

Unknowns

?Whether 'confirmed' is an official terminal approved state in the current payment provider API contract
?Whether the payment provider returns other status strings not currently handled by validatePaymentStatus
?Whether other callers of validatePaymentStatus exist outside the files identified in this analysis
?Whether this change was intentional (a deliberate narrowing of accepted statuses) or an accidental omission

Score is an informed estimate, not a guarantee. Human review determines merge readiness.

IBM Bob Evidence

Bob Mode

ci-triage

Session Report

Expected → bob_sessions/

MCP Tools Used

list_ci_runsget_ci_logget_remediation_reportget_repo_context_summary

Notes

→IBM Bob IDE analyzed the CI failure log using the local read-only MCP server — no external API calls were made
→Repository context (validatePaymentStatus.ts, checkout route, test file) was correlated with the CI log to identify probable root cause
→This report is a structured starting point for human investigation, not an automated fix decision
→The remediation plan contains safe read-only commands only — no write operations, no auto-commits
→Merge confidence score (2/10) reflects genuine uncertainty about the payment provider contract — not a definitive finding
→Exported IBM Bob IDE session report and screenshots must be added to bob_sessions/ before final hackathon submission

Recent CI Runs

5 runs

Run ID	Branch	Commit	Status	Duration	Timestamp
run_1042	main	a3f7c91	FAILED	46s	2026-05-16T21:00:00Z
run_1041	main	b2e5d80	PASSED	52s	2026-05-16T18:30:00Z
run_1040	feature/order-totals-refactor	c9f1a44	PASSED	49s	2026-05-16T15:15:00Z
run_1039	main	d4a7b32	PASSED	51s	2026-05-15T22:00:00Z
run_1038	main	e1c3f97	PASSED	48s	2026-05-15T14:30:00Z

Architecture

Data Flow

CI failure log→

Local read-only MCP→

IBM Bob IDE / Shell→

Structured report→

Dashboard

→ All data sourced from controlled local fixtures — no external API calls
→ Reproducible, credential-free, safe for public repositories
→ Architecture maps cleanly to future real CI integrations

Safety Boundaries

✓ No credentials

No API keys, tokens, or secrets anywhere in the repo

✓ No live API access

No external GitHub Actions, CircleCI, or Buildkite API calls

✓ No auto-fix

All code changes require a human engineer decision

✓ No auto-deploy

No deployment automation of any kind

✓ Read-only MCP

MCP server reads local fixture files only — no write operations

✓ Human review required

Merge confidence is an estimate. Human review determines readiness.